The alarm is not the fire.Symptoms such as binge eating, anxiety issues and eating disorder behaviors are alarms.
Stopping the anxiety or binge eating alarm without addressing what’s causing the alarm to sound off accomplishes little or nothing. It also can be dangerous because the metaphoric fire continues to burn and may increase in ferocity.
When a fire alarm goes off the problem is not the sound of the alarm. The problem is the fire. The deeper problem is the cause of the fire.
We are anxious for a reason, often not the reason we tell ourselves. We binge eat for a reason. Again, for the reason we tell ourselves. Anxiety andbinge eating are alarms signaling something needs attention.
In my opinion, we waste time, money and emotional weel being when we focus on the alarm. Too often we ignore or deny what causes the alarms to go off.
It’s also a waste of time and money to put out the fire without understanding the conditions that created. We remain ignorant and don't know how to take steps to prevent a blaze from flaring up again.
It doesn't make sense to run to the same emergency and never look to the cause.
In hillside communities of Los Angeles, California alarms sound at a fire. The fire department launches an attack on the flames. But we also keep dry brush away from our homes. We use non flammable materials for the roof. We clear brush, even to the extent of having goats graze the hillsides. Alarm, behavior, cause: All three need to be addressed.
People binge eat for suffer anxiety symptoms when something is not right in their lives. In California the most googled mental health search item involves intimacy issues.
Anxiety disorders and eating disorders are among the five major categories of mental illnesses. These three mental health issues have a variety of symptoms. Often symptoms will switch and change. A person can be left feeling that nothing is working or that they are personally failing because one symptom that seems to be decreasing is only revealing another which might be worse.
Intimacy Issues: Symptoms as Alarms
If a person is emotionally unavailable to her partner she
- lets him down when she knows she is needed,
- has relationships that rarely last more than 6 – 9 months,
- is wary of committing to a one on one relationship,
- avoids physical intimacy after three months,
- is more comfortable having sex with strangers
- continually questions in her own mind whether this person is the right partner for her.
These symptoms have a powerful effect on a relationships which will suffer or breakdown completely. She may avoid these symptoms if she protects herself and isolates herself from the possibility of any intimate relationship.
Anxiety: Symptoms as Alarms
If a person suffers from anxiety she has- panic attacks,
- physical symptoms such as pain, nausea and headaches,
- nightmares,
- obsessive thoughts,
- fear of leaving the house.
These symptoms can hamper her ability to function fully in her life.
Binge Eating and Eating Disorders: Symptoms as Alarms
- she eats too little or too much,
- binges,
- starves,
- feels anxiety around food and is compulsive about what and how she eats,
- is anxious and self-condemning about her weight and body shape,
- has a poor or distorted self-image.
Living with these alarm signals puts her physical health at risk, foils healthy relationships and limits her ability to use her energy more productively in her life.
Addressing these symptoms directly is an attempt to control the alarm. Using will power or self-lecturing or promising to stop or start a behavior is an attempt to control an unconscious process with the conscious mind.
Each of these issues means something to the person. Each behavior and feeling is often a defense around some past emotional damage that remains unaddressed or partially addressed and remains unhealed.
A person contacts a psychotherapist for help because she experiences the alarm. She doesn't know what's beneath her symptoms. She just knows she needs help.
Deep psychotherapy goes beneath the surface of behavior and conscious recognition. Deep psychotherapy responds to the alarm by going to the fire and then the cause. That’s what makes the necessary deep healing possible.
Joanna is a private psychotherapist in Los Angeles specializing in eating disorder recovery with women.
Joanna Poppink, MFT, is a psychotherapist in private practice specializing in eating disorder recovery. All appointments are virtual.
For a free telephone consultation e-mail her at
Author of
See map for most googled mental health searches by state in U.S.
